Skip to main content
Winter coverage check-up
Quote My Policy
Get a Quote

Local agents · South Carolina

Best independent insurance agencies in South Carolina

Local agencies that can compare more than one insurance company, ranked city by city with a formula you can check.

Disclosure: Quote My Policy is not an insurance agency and is not on this list. No agency paid to be listed or was asked to take part. The order comes from a published scoring formula applied to facts each agency publishes about itself. Our reviewers are licensed agents in Anderson: Joshua Pannell, Katie Stone and JJ Taylor work at Select Insurance, LLC, and our founder Bryan DeVore owns an agency. Those agencies are left off every list.

Reviewed by Bryan DeVore, Founder, Quote My Policy ·

Upstate

Greenville, SC

9 agencies ranked

  1. 1. The Morgano Agency
  2. 2. The Turner Agency, Inc.
  3. 3. Stansell Agency, LLC
See the full list →

Anderson, SC

6 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Kenneth Rhodes & Associates, Inc.
  2. 2. Citizens Insurance Agency
  3. 3. Electric City Insurance Services
See the full list →

Spartanburg, SC

6 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Correll Insurance Group of Spartanburg
  2. 2. CWS Insurance Agency
  3. 3. Compass Insurance Group LLC
See the full list →

Greer, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Countybanc Insurance (Greer)
  2. 2. Owens Insurance Agency
  3. 3. FCI Agency
See the full list →

Easley, SC

6 agencies ranked

  1. 1. R. Carl Byars Agency, Inc.
  2. 2. Poinsett General Insurance Agency, Inc.
  3. 3. The Grant Agency
See the full list →

Clemson & Seneca, SC

6 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Byrd-McLellan Agency, Inc.
  2. 2. Powell Insurance Group
  3. 3. Upstate Insurance Agency (Seneca)
See the full list →

Simpsonville, Mauldin & Fountain Inn, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Wickliffe Insurance Services
  2. 2. Chandler Insurance
  3. 3. Frontier Insurance Group
See the full list →

Midlands

Columbia, SC

9 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Adams Eaddy & Associates
  2. 2. Turbeville Insurance Agency (Columbia)
  3. 3. Smoak Insurance Agency, Inc
See the full list →

Lexington, SC

10 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Turbeville Insurance Agency (Lexington)
  2. 2. Midlands Insurance Center
  3. 3. First Carolina Insurance (Lexington)
See the full list →

Newberry, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Franklin-Summer Insurance
  2. 2. Bowers Floyd & Summer
  3. 3. Purcells Insurance & Loans
See the full list →

Sumter, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Creech Roddey Watson Insurance
  2. 2. Gamecock Insurance Agency
  3. 3. Dixon Blackwood Insurance
See the full list →

Orangeburg, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Wannamaker Agency
  2. 2. Taylor Agency (Orangeburg)
  3. 3. Santee Insurance Center (Orangeburg)
See the full list →

Aiken, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Hutson-Etherredge Companies
  2. 2. McCain Atkinson Insurance (Aiken)
  3. 3. Lambert Insurance Agency, Inc.
See the full list →

Irmo, West Columbia & Cayce, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Irmo Insurance Agency
  2. 2. Livingston Insurance Agency
  3. 3. Southeastern Insurance Consultants (Irmo)
See the full list →

York County

Rock Hill, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Peoples First Insurance
  2. 2. Carolinas Insurance & Investment Group
  3. 3. Wiley Insurance Services
See the full list →

Fort Mill & Tega Cay, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Springs Insurance (Fort Mill)
  2. 2. Crosswinds Insurance Agency (Fort Mill)
  3. 3. Brandon Price Insurance Agency (Fort Mill)
See the full list →

Lowcountry

Charleston, SC

8 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Maury Donnelly & Parr (Charleston)
  2. 2. Anderson Insurance Associates (Charleston)
  3. 3. C. T. Lowndes & Company (Charleston)
See the full list →

North Charleston, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Roe & Associates, Inc.
  2. 2. Ferguson Insurance Team (North Charleston)
  3. 3. W. C. Wilbur & Company (North Charleston)
See the full list →

Mount Pleasant, SC

12 agencies ranked

  1. 1. C. T. Lowndes & Company (Mount Pleasant)
  2. 2. Coastal Insurance Brokers (Mount Pleasant)
  3. 3. Schirmer Insurance Group
See the full list →

Summerville, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Taylor Agency (Summerville)
  2. 2. C. T. Lowndes & Company (Summerville)
  3. 3. Dotterer Insurance (Summerville)
See the full list →

Hilton Head Island, SC

5 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Correll Insurance Group of Hilton Head
  2. 2. Callen Insurance Services
  3. 3. PC&L Agency (Hilton Head Island)
See the full list →

Bluffton, SC

7 agencies ranked

  1. 1. AVEX Insurance
  2. 2. Hilton Head Insurance & Brokerage (Bluffton)
  3. 3. Harbor Light Insurance and Wealth Advisors
See the full list →

Beaufort & Port Royal, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Lowcountry Insurance Services
  2. 2. Kinghorn Insurance of Beaufort
  3. 3. Turbeville Insurance Agency (Beaufort)
See the full list →

Goose Creek & Moncks Corner, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. C. T. Lowndes & Company (Moncks Corner)
  2. 2. Cheri Nelson Insurance Agency
  3. 3. J. Philip Morgan Agency
See the full list →

Pee Dee & Grand Strand

Florence, SC

8 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Accountable Insurance Partners (Florence)
  2. 2. CSP Insurance Services
  3. 3. Ed Smith Insurance Agency
See the full list →

Myrtle Beach, SC

6 agencies ranked

  1. 1. John T. Cook & Associates
  2. 2. Peoples Underwriters (Myrtle Beach)
  3. 3. The Insurance House of Myrtle Beach
See the full list →

North Myrtle Beach, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Coastal Insurance Brokers (North Myrtle Beach)
  2. 2. Davis Insurance Associates (North Myrtle Beach)
  3. 3. Perry Insurance Group (North Myrtle Beach)
See the full list →

Conway, SC

4 agencies ranked

  1. 1. Peoples Underwriters, Inc.
  2. 2. Bradham Insurance Agency
  3. 3. Fogner Insurance Agency
See the full list →

By coverage

How we rank

The 100-point formula, who qualifies, and what we never use.

Check an agent’s license

How to look up any South Carolina agent yourself, step by step.

Facts checked October 29, 2026.

CallGet a Quote