Best Pet Insurance Comparison Sites (2026)
Disclosure: Quote My Policy wrote this list and ranks itself first. Quote My Policy LLC connects you with licensed insurance professionals. It is not an insurance company and does not issue policies. Every other service here is described only from its own website, as of the date below.
Where to compare pet insurance, and what each site does with your details.
Facts checked September 23, 2026
Pet insurance plans look similar until you compare the details: the deductible, reimbursement rate, annual limit, waiting periods and how hereditary and chronic conditions are handled. A comparison site can save hours, as long as it compares plans like for like.
Most comparison sites are paid by the insurers, either a commission when you buy or a referral fee when you ask for a quote. That's normal, but it's worth knowing. Each entry below says how the site describes its own pay and what it says about contacting you.
How we picked
Compares several insurers
A real side-by-side, not one company's plans dressed up as a comparison.
Clear about how it's paid
We favored sites that explain their commission or referral fees.
Clear about contact
What the site's own privacy wording says about emails and calls.
The list
1. Quote My Policy
Best for: Pet insurance quoted alongside your other policies
Quote My Policy quotes pet insurance with the rest of your household's coverage. It publishes plain-English guides to deductibles, reimbursement, waiting periods and pre-existing conditions, so you know what you're comparing before you choose.
You fill in a short, three-step form or call, and choose how you'd like to be reached: phone, text or email. Quote My Policy connects you with licensed insurance professionals. It's not an insurance company and doesn't issue policies. Quotes are free and there's no obligation to buy.
When you submit a request, your details may be shared with licensed insurance professionals who may contact you about it. The privacy policy explains how.
- Quotes home, renters, auto and motorcycle, life, mortgage protection, pet, business and boat insurance
- Online form or phone: 864-387-2746
- You pick phone, text or email as your contact preference
- Free calculators, a glossary and state-by-state guides on the site
- Pet insurance cost, coverage and quote calculators
2. Pawlicy Advisor
Best for: Side-by-side plan comparison with a licensed expert on hand
An online pet insurance marketplace and licensed brokerage in Scarsdale, New York. You enter your pet's details, compare providers side by side and customize coverage, then buy through the site or talk to a licensed expert.
- Says it's paid a commission by the insurer when you buy through it
3. Pet Insurance Review
Best for: Comparing quotes and reading owner reviews together
Founded in 2003 and run by Pets Rule LLC in Denver, it gives real-time quotes from more than 24 US and Canadian providers based on your pet's breed, age, weight and location. It also hosts policyholder reviews of each provider.
- Says its only revenue is a referral fee paid by the insurer when you request a quote
- Says it doesn't pass your details to any insurer unless you request a quote
4. PetInsuranceQuotes.com
Best for: A simple four-step compare-and-enroll flow
Run by Pet Insurance Quotes, LLC in Seattle. You fill in a short form for each pet, compare plans and prices, and enroll. It says it's licensed in all 50 states and DC and isn't tied to any one provider.
- Says partner insurers pay it a fee if you enroll, not passed on to you
- Its privacy policy says insurers may use what you submit to contact you directly
5. Insurify
Best for: Pet quotes from a multi-line comparison site
Insurify, based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, compares car, home and other insurance, and has a pet section. Pet quotes are sourced through a partner agency, Fletch Insurance Services, from a network of more than 10 partner insurers.
- Says it earns an agent commission only if you buy
Comparing plans properly
Set every quote to the same deductible, reimbursement rate and annual limit before you compare prices. Then check the differences that don't show up in the price: waiting periods, hereditary and chronic condition rules, exam fees and dental illness.
Want quotes for your situation?
Tell us what you need and how you’d like to be reached. Quote My Policy LLC connects you with licensed insurance professionals. Quotes are free, with no obligation to buy.
Common questions
Yes, for you. They're usually paid by insurers, either a commission when you buy or a referral fee when you request a quote. Reputable sites explain how they're paid.
Possibly. Some sites share your request with insurers who may contact you directly. Check the site's privacy policy before you submit.
Waiting periods, how hereditary and chronic conditions are handled, exam fees, dental illness, and whether the annual limit is enough for a major surgery.
Keep reading
General information only, not insurance advice. Coverage, availability and terms vary by insurer and by state, and are subject to underwriting. Quote My Policy LLC connects you with licensed insurance professionals. Quote My Policy is not an insurance company and does not issue policies. Nothing here binds coverage.