Skip to main content
Quote My Policy

New York Car Insurance: Three Required Protections and the Plates Rule

What the law actually requires, and why it usually isn’t enough.

Every figure on this page is sourced and dated. Requirements change when legislatures amend them, so we say where ours came from and when we last checked.

Reviewed by Katie Stone, Licensed Property & Casualty Insurance Agent (SC license #711636) ·

Source-checked October 30, 2026 against the official New York sources listed below.

In New York, buying the required insurance and keeping the registration record correct are inseparable. A registered car needs New York-issued liability insurance even when you are not driving it. Your policy also needs basic no-fault benefits and mandatory uninsured motorist protection. A liability-only shorthand such as “25/50/10” does not describe the entire required package.1 2

For a personal car, start with the following requirements:

  • Bodily injury liability: $25,000 for nonfatal injury to one person and $50,000 for nonfatal injuries to two or more people in one crash.
  • Death liability: $50,000 for one person’s death and $100,000 for deaths of two or more people in one crash, subject to the per-person limit.
  • Property damage liability: $10,000 per crash.
  • Basic no-fault/PIP: $50,000 per person for qualifying economic losses.
  • Uninsured motorist bodily injury protection: the required minimum bodily injury limits, commonly expressed as $25,000/$50,000; the mandatory coverage addresses qualifying New York accidents.1 2

There are separate decisions about higher limits, supplementary uninsured/underinsured protection, spousal liability and damage to your own car. Work through those choices before comparing premiums.

First, keep insurance and registration in sync

New York DMV requires liability coverage issued by an appropriately licensed and DMV-certified insurer. Out-of-state insurance is not accepted for a vehicle registered in New York. The name on the insurance and registration must match exactly; if there are two registrants, both names must appear on the insurance ID card.1

The insurer supplies your insurance ID card and sends an electronic coverage notice to DMV. DMV needs both; possession of an ID card alone does not establish that its electronic record is correct. Your agent or broker cannot submit that electronic notice in place of the insurer.1

Check names, VIN and effective date before registration. If you receive an insurance letter from DMV despite having coverage, respond and contact the insurer rather than assuming the letter will disappear. Keep proof of your communications and confirm that the record has been corrected.

The requirement continues while the registration is valid, including when the car sits unused. For an ordinary passenger car, DMV’s instruction is to surrender the registration and plates before New York coverage ends if you are not replacing that coverage. Simply parking the car, removing a battery or canceling a payment does not close the registration record.1 3

When changing insurers, arrange the new coverage to start before the old coverage ends, with no uninsured interval. If you are taking the car off the road, confirm the plate-surrender procedure before canceling. DMV says any period of registered-but-uninsured time can create a lapse and can lead to registration or driver-license suspension. Its practical rule is “no insurance, no plates.”3

Understand what no-fault pays—and what it does not

Basic no-fault, also called PIP, pays qualifying economic losses without first deciding which driver caused the crash. Its $50,000 per-person limit includes reasonable and necessary medical and rehabilitation expenses, wage-loss benefits and certain other necessary expenses. It does not pay for repairing your car.2

The wage-loss benefit is not full salary replacement. DFS describes payment of 80% of lost earnings, capped at $2,000 per month for up to three years, with statutory offsets. Other reasonable and necessary expenses can be reimbursed up to $25 a day for up to a year. A $2,000 death benefit is additional to the basic $50,000 no-fault limit.2

Hypothetical example: a covered injury keeps you from earning $5,000 a month. Even though 80% would be $4,000, the basic monthly wage-loss cap is $2,000 before considering applicable offsets and other conditions. A $50,000 headline limit therefore should not be read as a promise to replace your regular income.

Ask about Additional PIP if you want a higher overall limit or different benefit levels. Insurers must also offer Optional Basic Economic Loss, or OBEL. Buying OBEL adds $25,000 beyond the basic $50,000 economic-loss coverage; after the basic amount is exhausted, the injured person can designate how that additional amount applies among permitted categories, such as wage loss or rehabilitation.2

No-fault rules also affect lawsuits. Recovery for pain and suffering generally requires a “serious injury” as defined by New York insurance law. Economic loss beyond no-fault benefits can raise separate liability questions. Do not assume that using PIP means fault no longer matters, or that every injury supports a pain-and-suffering lawsuit.2

Mandatory uninsured coverage and SUM solve different problems

New York’s compulsory uninsured motorist coverage protects against qualifying bodily injuries caused by uninsured or hit-and-run drivers. The mandatory coverage applies to accidents in New York and does not repair your car. It is not broad underinsured motorist protection simply because the policy includes the word “uninsured.”2

Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorists coverage, or SUM, expands protection to qualifying out-of-state accidents and situations involving another driver whose bodily injury liability limits are lower than yours. SUM cannot exceed your bodily injury liability limits.2

DFS says an insurer initially includes SUM at limits equal to your bodily injury liability limits unless you decline SUM or select a lower amount through the required signed or electronically signed form. Mandatory uninsured protection is not eliminated by declining this optional expansion. Ask to see both the declarations and any selection form, particularly if a cheaper quote has different SUM limits.2

SUM is also not necessarily an extra pot added in full to the other driver’s payment. DFS explains that recoveries from another party’s liability policy offset SUM benefits. Ask the agent to show how your proposed limits would operate after a recovery from the at-fault driver. The amount available depends on policy terms, applicable limits and covered damages—not merely the number printed beside SUM.

A married driver’s additional coverage question

Supplemental Spousal Liability insurance concerns liability for injuries to an insured’s spouse. It is different from the spouse’s eligibility for no-fault benefits. Declining spousal liability coverage can therefore change one form of protection without removing the other.2

DFS’s current guidance says that when a new applicant indicates they are married, the insurer provides notice that spousal liability coverage is included unless declined, explains the coverage and premium, and supplies a declination form. Applicants who do not indicate they are married receive notice of availability. Existing coverage generates renewal or amendment notices explaining inclusion unless declined.2

Review that notice rather than assuming marriage automatically settles every coverage question. If your marital status changes or you are considering a declination to lower premium, ask the insurer to explain the effect using your actual household circumstances.

The $10,000 property limit is not protection for your car

Property damage liability pays covered damage you cause to other people’s property. With only a $10,000 limit, a crash can leave substantial uncovered liability. Hypothetically, $28,000 in covered damage to another car would exceed that limit by $18,000. The bodily injury limit cannot be reassigned to fill the property damage shortfall.

Your own vehicle requires a separate decision. Collision covers qualifying crash damage, while comprehensive addresses qualifying noncollision losses such as theft, flood, fire or animal contact. These are optional under the ordinary state minimum package, though financing or leasing can require them. Compare deductibles you could actually pay and ask whether substitute transportation is covered while repairs are underway.2

Put the choices into one comparable quote

Use identical liability, SUM, PIP enhancements, physical damage limits and deductibles when comparing offers. Confirm spousal coverage selections, all regular drivers, vehicle use and the exact registration names. Review the full policy period and installment charges as well as the initial payment.

You can request an auto insurance quote once those choices are clear. Keep existing coverage active until the replacement is effective, or follow DMV’s registration-and-plate procedure if the vehicle is leaving the road.

General information only, not individualized insurance or legal advice. Confirm selections with a licensed insurance professional and obtain qualified legal advice about injury claims or disputed coverage.

Official sources

  1. New York DMV — New York State Insurance Requirements. Liability limits, death limits, names, New York coverage and insurer reporting.
  2. New York DFS — Auto Insurance Information for Consumers. No-fault, uninsured coverage, SUM, spousal liability, OBEL and vehicle coverage.
  3. New York DMV — Insurance Lapses. Registered-but-uninsured periods, plate surrender and consequences.

New York car insurance questions

  • New York requires at least 25/50/10 — $25,000 of bodily injury liability per person, $50,000 per accident, and $10,000 of property damage liability. Verified 2026-08-17.

Get a New York quote

We’ll connect you with a licensed insurance professional who can compare coverage across multiple carriers rather than sell one company’s product.

Requirements verified 2026-08-17 against Insurance Information Institute / APCIA, rev. 7/2024. State insurance law changes — confirm current requirements with the New York State Department of Financial Services before relying on any figure here. General information only, not legal or insurance advice. Quote My Policy LLC connects you with licensed insurance professionals.