Run your budget on one income
The exercise that makes the coverage question concrete.
Deciding how much coverage you need in the abstract is hard. Deciding it after you've seen what happens to your actual budget is much easier.
This takes about twenty minutes and a bank statement.
Step one: list what doesn't stop
Take a month of statements and mark every cost that would continue regardless. The mortgage, utilities, insurance, food, transport, childcare, minimum debt payments.
These are the ones that don't care what happened to your household. That total is the number to work from.
Step two: remove one income
Subtract the higher earner's take-home pay, then the lower earner's, and look at both results. Households often assume the answer is obvious and find it isn't.
Also add anything that would become a paid expense — childcare currently covered by a parent's time is the most common and most underestimated.
Step three: see how long savings last
Divide available savings by the monthly shortfall. That's your runway in months, and it's usually a sobering number.
Runway is the real question. Insurance isn't there to replace an income forever — it's there to make sure nobody has to sell the house in month four.
The same exercise, with round numbers
An illustration, with invented round figures—substitute your own. Say the costs that do not stop come to $3,800 a month, and the surviving income is $2,900. The shortfall is $900 a month. With $18,000 of savings genuinely available, the runway is twenty months.
Now the coverage question has edges. Clearing the mortgage removes the largest single line from the $3,800 and may close the shortfall on its own. Covering the shortfall instead—$900 a month for ten years—takes $108,000 of cover, and leaves the mortgage in place. Many households need a mix, and the mix is exactly what this exercise reveals.
Step four: decide what you're buying
Now the coverage question is concrete: enough to clear the mortgage, enough to cover the shortfall for a number of years, or both.
That's a decision you can actually make, and it's a much better brief to take to a licensed professional than "how much do I need?"
Frequently asked questions
How long does the exercise take?
About twenty minutes with a month of bank statements. Mark what continues, remove one income at a time, and divide available savings by the monthly shortfall to get your runway in months.
Should cover clear the mortgage or cover the shortfall?
Either can be right. Clearing the mortgage removes the largest continuing cost; covering the shortfall keeps cash flexible. The exercise shows which one actually closes your household's gap.
What is the most commonly missed cost?
Paid replacements for unpaid work—childcare a parent was providing is the usual one, and it lands at exactly the moment income falls.
Want this checked for your situation?
General information only. A licensed insurance professional can tell you what actually applies to you.
Sources
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC): Tips for Buying Life Insurance (checked November 6, 2026)
Reviewed by
Joshua H. Pannell
Licensed Insurance Agent | Agency Owner | Insurance Content Expert
Joshua H. Pannell brings more than 23 years of insurance industry experience to his role as an insurance content contributor and expert reviewer for Quote My Policy. An Agent Owner at Select Insurance, LLC, and licensed in Property & Casualty and Life, Accident & Health insurance, he works across personal and commercial lines, with a particular interest in helping small business owners understand their coverage needs.
SC license #400481. Full bio and license numbers
General information only, not insurance advice. Coverage, availability, and terms vary by insurer and by state. Quote My Policy LLC connects you with licensed insurance professionals.